Beyond AI adoption: What nonprofit leaders need to know about responsible AI policies

AI is quickly becoming part of everyday work across the social sector. Whether it’s drafting communications, analyzing data, streamlining administrative tasks, or exploring new ways to advance mission outcomes, AI is reshaping how work gets done—and what mission-driven work is possible.

But as recent research from the Blackbaud Institute found, while 85% of nonprofit professionals are using AI at work, only about one-third believe their organizations are using it very effectively. And only 10% of nonprofits have reached a level of AI maturity where they’re seeing transformational results. They’re the ones investing in the skills, practices, and structures that turn experimentation into meaningful outcomes. I believe there are three things that matter most for responsible AI adoption.

1. AI literacy is becoming a foundational leadership skill

Conversations about AI tend to focus on technology, but the focus should be on people. We don’t need everyone to become data scientists or AI experts. But we do need staff and leaders who understand the fundamentals: what AI can do, where it creates value, where it introduces risk, and how to evaluate new tools responsibly.

Without a clear roadmap from leadership that articulates how an organization is going to responsibly and effectively use AI, individual teams might experiment independently, which can introduce potential risk and inefficiency. A common baseline of AI knowledge and clear policies and practices on responsible AI use creates the foundation for everything that follows.

2. Responsible AI isn’t a compliance exercise—it’s a trust strategy

Donors, volunteers, constituents, students, patients, and communities place extraordinary trust in the organizations they support. As AI becomes more embedded in nonprofit operations, maintaining that trust becomes even more important.

That’s why we need to view responsible AI practices as more than a technical requirement. Leaders should be asking questions such as:

• How are AI-generated outputs reviewed?
• What role should AI play in the decision-making process?
• How do we communicate transparently about AI use?
• What safeguards are needed to protect sensitive information?
• How do we ensure AI supports—not undermines—our mission and values?

The organizations that answer these questions proactively and adopt responsible AI policies will maintain their communities’ trust—and, in turn, will be better positioned to scale AI confidently and sustainably.

3. The goal isn’t use—it’s organizational readiness for responsible AI policies

One of the most revealing findings from our research is that widespread AI use hasn’t automatically translated into widespread impact. We call that impact the AI Maturity Dividend: the compounding return organizations earn when AI-driven time savings are reinvested into revenue and mission critical work—rather than absorbed as fragmented, individual productivity—and AI drives increased outcomes in core operational areas. This only happens when organizations move deliberately—investing in governance, data readiness, and transparency— with a roadmap that focuses on ground-up transformation rather than approaching AI as a productivity tool.

The most successful organizations are creating shared language around AI, establishing clear expectations with formal policies for sensitive data, ensuring human review of AI outputs, and assigning clear accountability for AI decisions. They’re developing AI maturity, not just AI access.

In many ways, this mirrors other periods of technological change. The organizations that thrive aren’t simply the earliest adopters. They’re the ones who intentionally create the mechanisms that ensure organizational confidence, alignment, and willingness to adapt to new technology over time.

Closing the gap together with resources for nonprofits

The good news is that the social impact sector is not starting from scratch.

Across nonprofits, foundations, educational institutions, health care organizations, and corporate social impact teams, leaders are actively sharing knowledge and building best practices. The AI Coalition for Social Impact was created to support that effort by bringing together a diverse range of experts dedicated to removing barriers to AI adoption for the social sector. Members ranging from tech and AI companies, to responsible AI think tanks, to nonprofit industry associations and corporate impact organizations, are putting their combined weight behind a unified effort to deliver on the promise of AI for social good.

The coalition’s flagship initiative is the free, product-agnostic AI for Social Impact Certification Program, which was designed to provide practical, accessible education tailored specifically to social impact professionals. The first course, “Fundamentals for Social Impact,” is now live.

But the broader objective is much bigger than any single program. It’s about ensuring that as AI reshapes the future of work, the organizations tackling society’s most important challenges have equal access to the knowledge, tools, and confidence needed to benefit from it.

Photo credit: Pressmaster/Getty Images

Candid insights publication guidelines